A year ago tonight we were dining with my folks at the little Mom-and-Pop Italian restaurant near my childhood home. I remember that you, naturally, ordered chicken parmesan over capellini – I’ll never forget how the first time you ever took me out to dinenr, you told me that dish was the way to your heart. On my birthday weekend, you picked up the check, completely winning over my father. You said it was to say ‘Thank you’ for allowing the two of us to stay with them for a couple of nights. We had been to my hometown twice before, but this third trip was the first we’d stayed with my parents in lieu of a hotel. It didn’t occur to me then that it would also be the last trip we’d take together.
The next morning we brunched; after years of my picturing a future with you, you were finally meeting my closest friends, and I was thrilled. Nervous, because their opinion of you meant so much to me, but confident enough that you’d charm them. And you did – it wasn’t more than a couple of hours before they were texting me how much they liked you and how comfortable we seemed to be around each other.
We spent the afternoon in the city that I adore, walking, treasure hunting, enjoying the weather and the sights and each other. That evening, it was you who suggested that we stay in my with parents. We played Phase 10 around the dining room table – my mother’s favorite – and ate and laughed and it felt easy and joyous and I was home and you belonged there with me. You told me later that you were really pleased with our decision to stay in – not only because we enjoyed ourselves so much, but because of something my father had said earlier that weekend: he had made some off-handed comment about never seeing my younger brother, who lived only 30 minutes away, and you thought that my dad would likely prefer to have me home, on this rare visit to southwestern Pennsylvania. Your thoughtfulness made me swoon.
After your Phase 10 winning streak, we retired to our separate rooms – you don’t share a room with a member of the opposite sex in my parents’ house if you’re not married – but it wasn’t long before you were unconvincingly insisting that you didn’t want to disrespect my parents by touching me in their house, while simultaneously physically encouraging me as we started to fool around. We spent the next several hours talking in hushed tones, giggling, cuddling, kissing…it was the most intimate and vulnerable I had ever felt with you. Somewhere between midnight and 1:00 am you pulled me close, kissed my forehead, and wished me a happy birthday. We had sex so memorable it was borderline love-making, and you still bring it up, even now.
That weekend, as low-key and unassuming as it was, was by far my best and favorite birthday in 35 years. It was better than the big “garage party” I threw for myself in the 6th grade, when my boyfriend Cory Horvath gave me gold stud earrings, marking the second and last time in my life a guy has gifted me jewelry. It was better than the birthday in my mid-20s, when the Red Lobster waitstaff went to Madison’s house after our shifts, and we all drank way too much and passed out on the trampoline in his back yard. It was even better than my 30th birthday, when I fulfilled a lifelong dream and treated myself to a week in Paris, where I ate almond croissants and duck confit and macarons and unabashedly played Tourist in the City of Lights. The way I felt with you, this weekend last year, was the best I’d ever felt about myself, about us, about our future. It was the happiest I ever remember being.
Today likely would have passed like any other Saturday had you not called. Though we’d chatted casually, we haven’t seen each other in a month, and when chunks of time like this pass, I forget about you long enough to forget why I need to in the first place. But you call, unexpectedly, and try to makes plans to take me out for my birthday…and then I spend the rest of the day in my head, feeling sorry for myself that the ONLY person that has attempted to make plans with me was the one person that I can’t bear the thought of being with on my birthday.


